Efficacy of mineral and organic adsorbent in alleviating harmful effects of Zearalenone on pigs performance and health

Summary

Two trials, 31 and 29 days long, were conducted to study the performance and health of pigs treated with different amounts of Zearalenone and to investigate the feasibility of utilizing a modified clinoptilolite and esterified glucomannan in alleviating and/or preventing its harmful effects.

NESIC KSENIJA*, RESANOVIC RADMILA**, NESIC V** and SINOVEC Z**
*Scientific Institute of Veterinary Medicine of Serbia, Belgrade, Serbia
**Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Belgrade, Serbia
Fumonisina

Introduction

According to toxicity and frequency of appearance in nature, Zearalenone (ZON toxin) is one of the most important mycotoxins of Fusarium fungi that are widely spread in Europe (Bottalico and Perrone, 2002; Logrieco et al., 2002).
Corn is usually affected, especially hybrids with a long vegetation and high humidity at the moment of harvest, but the fungi growth and toxin synthesis extends further during storage (EFSA, 2004). (EFSA, 2004).

Biological activity

Biological activity of this toxin can be explained as:
  • Competition with 17 ß oestradiol for the specific binding sites at estrogenic receptors:
  • Interpherence with enzymes that are involved in the metabolism of steroids (Mitterbauer et al., 2003).
  • F-2 toxin exerts its effects in all metabolic processes that are under the influence of estrogenic hormones, usually on the genital tract and in reproduction (D'Mello et al., 1999).
Doses that are much greater than concentrations which have hormonal effects may have genotoxic and carcinogenic effects (National Toxicology Program, 2002).

Zearalenone

Pigs are sensitive

Pigs are more sensitive than other animal species.(Gaumy et al., 2001)
  • Primarily manifesting hyperestrogenism in females
  • Gastrointestinal lesions
  • Effects on the liver
  • Alterations of serum clinical chemical parameters (D'Mello et al., 1999; Döll et al., 2003, Döll et al., 2005)

Clinical Signs

Hyperemia and edema of vulva with a lightly clouded mucilaginous vaginal discharge are symptoms of intoxication.
In severe cases vaginal and rectal prolapses can be seen.
Clinical signs are more expressed in immature than in mature animals (Doll et al., 2003).
Diarrhoea, vomiting, feed refusal, body weight loss and haemorrhages also can be seen in the clinical picture, but not only as the consequence of zearalenone influence, but by its synergistic effect with other toxins present in the feed contaminated with Fusarium fungi (D'Mello et al., 1999).

Clinoptilolite

Adsorbents

The use of adsorbents is the most frequent way of alleviating and/or preventing harmful effects of mycotoxins.
Adsorbents are substances nonresorbable from the gut that can physically bind some chemicals and thus block their resorption.
Several commercially available adsorbents which claimed to bind mycotoxins were tested for both in vitro and in vivo adsorption.
Most studies have used aluminosilicates such as modified clinoptilolite (Tomasevic- Canovi} et al., 2003; Döll et al., 2004, Döll et al., 2005).
The feasibility of utilizing organic adsorbents was recently examined.
Esterified glucomannan, which belongs to this group, (Devegowda et al., 1998; Swamy, 2002) is isolated from the inner layer of yeast cell wall and which possesses a significant capability for mycotoxin adsorption.
The primary objective of this study was not only to investigate the performance and health of pigs treated with different amounts of F-2 toxin, but also to assess the feasibility of utilizing a modified clinoptilolite and esterified glucomannan aimed at alleviating and/or preventing its harmful effects.

Material and methods

Piglet
Animals.
  • Two trials were performed on a total of 64 pigs of Swedish and Dutch Landrace cross-breed.
  • Pigs were of both sexes with 14.40 kg and 16.30 kg average body weight, 60 days old and kept in breeding pens.
  • Microclimate and hygienic conditions were appropriate for this category of pigs.
Diets.
  • All groups of pigs were fed with a commercial feed mixture (grower 15-25 kg) which consisted of standard feedstuffs and contained enough nutrients to satisfy the requirements of this category.
  • Corn naturally contaminated with Zearalenone (12.8 mg/kg) was used in the amount of 30% in experimental groups of the first trial and 40% in the second trial.
  • Zearalenone free corn was given to pigs in the control groups.
  • Mineral adsorbent Minazel Plus® was introduced in the contaminated feed of the second experimental groups and organic adsorbent Mycosorb® in the contaminated feed of the third experimental groups of both trials.

Data and sample collection.
  • The following data were monitored during the trials:
    • body weight (BW),
    • weight gain (AWG),
    • feed intake (FI)
    • feed conversion ratio (FCR)
    .
  • Control measurments of the experimental pigs were done on a technical scale with 10-2 kg precision.
    According to these results average body weight was calculated.
  • Total weight gain was obtained from body weight difference and daily weight gain was calculated according to duration of the trials.
  • The amount of mixes given to each group was measured precisely during both experiments.
  • Feed intake was identified after adding of daily amounts of feed at the and of the trials.
  • Feed conversion ratio was calculated according to feed intake and weight gain data for both experiments.
  • Every day observations were done with special interest to occurrence of diarrhea and vulvovaginitis.
  • Vulvovaginitis severity was determined according to vulvar index (Evans, 2000) which was the result of the multiplication of vulvar width and length.
  • Six pigs per group were sacrificed at the end of the trials.
  • Immediately after sacrifice necropsy and detailed macroscopic examinations were carried out.
  • In the shortest possible period samples of vagina were taken for histological investigations.
  • Vagina samples were fixed in 10% neutral formalin and absolute alcohol, embedded in paraffin, sections of 5-8 mthickness cut and stained using the standard hematoxylin eosin method (Scheuer and Chalk, 1986).

Results and discussion

Pigs were of adequate body weight for their breed and age at the beginning of the trials and differences were not statistically significant (p>0.05). Performance differed at the end of the trials between control and experimental groups, and also between trials depending on toxin concentracions.

Pigs in the control groups achieved the largest body weight, top weight gain and the lowest feed conversion ratio.
According to literature data it was concluded that these results were common for breed, sex, age and rearing conditions.

By comparing experimental groups of pigs fed with contaminated feed with control groups it can be noted that Zearalenone had a harmful influence on body weight which was decreased proportionally to its amount in the feed (p>0.05) i.e. for 10.84% in the first trial and for 11.13% in the second trial.
Although body weight is a respectable parameter, daily weight gain is reputed as a better indicator of feed quality. Weight

Zootechnical conditions and animal health

It is particularly the indicator of zootechnical conditions and animal health (Table 1). By comparing experimental groups (O-I) to control groups (K) considerably lower daily weight gain, for 19.86% (p< 0.05), was seen in the first experiment and 22.27% in the second one.

Table 1. Weight gain* of pigs during the trials, kg

Variation * Value expressed as x±Sd a, b, c, d p <0.05
  • Application of adsorbents ensured a significant recompense of lost body weight, i.e. it provided satisfactory daily growth.
  • Average body weight and daily weight gain of pigs fed with contaminated feed with addition of adsorbents were still lower than control values, but at the same time higher than average body weight and daily weight gain of pigs fed with contaminated feed without protectors.
  • There was not any difference in the results due to type of adsorbent.
It could be concluded that utilizing modified clinoptilolite and esterified Glucomannan was not enough for performance of usual body weight, i.e. it could not entirely prevent harmful effects of Zearalenone, even at its lowest dosage. But, usage of adsorbents alleviated harmful effects of F-2 toxin also in the case of its higher content in the feed.
Presence of F-2 toxin reduced feed intake for 5.89% in the first trial and 1.52% in the second trial, but the application of adsorbents entirely eliminated harmful effects.
Pigs fed with feed contaminated with a lower quantity of Zearalenone with addition of adsorbents achieved larger consumption than pigs fed with the same feed without protectors, but it was still lower than in the control groups.
Pigs fed with feed contaminated with higher amount of Zearalenone with addition of adsorbents reached larger feed intake, compared to pigs in the control groups.
There was no significant difference in the results due to type of adsorbent.
Piglet

Feed conversion ratio

Feed conversion ratio, as interaction of weight gain and feed intake, differed between control and experimental groups (Table 2).
Experimental groups fed with contaminated feed reached a higher feed conversion ratio, proportionall to Zearalenone feed content, i.e. 14.82% in the first trial and 21.08% in the second one.
Table 2. Feed conversion ratio during the trials, kg
Feed Conversion

Utilization of adsorbents significantly alleviated harmful effects of Zearalenone, but not entirely.

  • Feed conversion ratio of pigs fed contaminated feed with the addition of modified clinoptilolite was still higher than control values for 6.52% in the first trial and 8.83% in the second trial, but it was lower than feed conversion ratio of pigs who received contaminated feed only.
  • Feed conversion ratio of pigs fed contaminated feed with the addition of esterified Glucomannan was also higher than control values (6.37% in the first experiment and 9.06% in the second) and it was lower than conversion ratio in groups of pigs which did not get adsorbents.
  • Döll et al. (2003) also reported that feed intake and, consequently, body weight gain of female weaned piglets receaving Fusarium toxin contaminated diet (ZON 0.42 mg/kg and DON 3.9 mg/kg) were significantly decreased, while the feed conversion ratio was not affected by this treatment.

Clinical signs

Regarding clinical signs this intoxication was manifested by vulvovaginitis in female pigs, but also by nonspecific symptoms of gastrointestinal disorders follow by diarrhea.

Vulvovaginitis occurrence was noticed in all experimental groups of pigs since the third day of ingesting contaminated feed.

Swine
Vulvar index (Evans, 2000) showed the severity of symptoms with success (Table 3).
Vulvar oedema could be seen in groups of pigs fed with contaminated mixture without of adsorbents for 10- 15 days after dispossession of this feed.
This symptom was less obvious by addition of adsorbents and it was present for 5-10 days after disuse of contaminated feed.


Table 3. Vulvar index Vulvar index *Value expressed as x±Sd a, b, c, d p <0.05 x, y, z, w p ≤<0.01

Morphological examination of the genital organs of pigs fed with Zearalenone contaminated feed showed macroscopic changes in the form of vulvovaginitis primarily manifested with oedema.
Histological findings of epithelial hyperplasia and submucous oedema were present mostly in pigs that were not given any feed protectors.

Use of adsorbents as toxin binders, especially the organic one, fairly alleviated negative effects of Zearalenone. Clinoptilolite

Gastrointestinal disorders

  • The outbreak of gastrointestinal disorders was also observed.
  • It was noticed since the third day of usage of contaminated feed without added adsorbents, and since the seventh day in groups of pigs that were given protectors.
  • The majority of affected pigs was seen in groups with no added adsorbents in the feed.
It is believed that this might be result of the presence of other Fusarium mycotoxins which co-occur in the feed. In general, combinations of Fusarium mycotoxins result in additive effects, but synergistic and/or potentiating interactions have been observed and are of great concern in livestock health and productivity. (D'Mello et al., 1999; Jadamus and Schneider, 2002).
In practice F-2 toxicosis is usually expressed in a nonspecific form as chronic primary mycotoxicosis followed by impaired growth, decreased body weight, lower feed intake and consequently increase of feed conversion ratio (Humphreys, 1988).
Observing performances cumulatively for both experiments it can be found that Zearalenone provoked harmful effects proportionally to its content in the feed (Doll et al., 2003), although this was not obviously clinically noted in the trials considering their similar duration and only a 1.16 mg/kg dosage difference.
Application of the inorganic adsorbent alleviated the harmful influence of Zearalenone to a certain extend, what is in agreement with remarks of Coenen and Boyens (2001), Tomasevic-Canovi et al. (2003), Döll et al. (2004) in in vitro conditions, but much less information is available about in vivo trials (Kyriakis et al., 2002; Döll et al., 2005).
Similar results are observed by utilizing an esterified Glucomannan, but still lower than those reported by Devegowda and Aravind (2002) and Aravind et al. (2003).
Based upon the obtained results, it could be concluded that Zearalenone induces detrimental alterations of health and performance in pigs.
Addition of modified clinoptilolite and esterified Glucomannan in the feed significantly alleviates harmful Zearalenone effects.
Thus, the use of adsorbents as toxin binders could be an efficient approach to reduce mycotoxin effects in animals to a certain extant.
However, only absolute disuse of this kind of feed is a safe and efficient method of avoiding mycotoxins.
1. Aravind KL, Patil VS, Devegowda G, Umakhanta B, Ganpule SP, 2003, Efficacy of esterified glucomannan to counteract mycotoxicosis in naturally contaminated feed on performance and serum biochemical, hematological parameters in broilers, Poult. Sci. 82, 571-6. 2. Bottalico A, Perrone G, 2002, Toxigenic Fusarium species and mycotoxins associated with head blight in small-grain cereals in Europe, Eur J Plant Pathol, 108, 611-24. 3. Coenen M, Boyens B, 2001, Capacity of zeolithe to depress the oestrogenic effects of Zearalenone, Proc Soc Nutr Physiol, 10, 177. 4. Devegowda G, Raju M, Afzali N, Swamy H, 1998, Mycotoxin picture worldwide: Novel solutions for their counteraction. Proceedings of Alltech's 14th Annual Symposium on Biotechnology in the Feed Industry, 241-55. 5. Devegowda G, Aravind KL, 2002, Mycotoxins: Economic risk and control. Alltech 16th Lecture Tour, 59-73. 6. D'Mello JPF, Placinta CM, Macdonald AMC, 1999, Fusarium mycotoxins: a review of global implications for animal health, welfare and productivity, Anim Feed Sci Technol 80, 183-205. 7. Döll S, Dänicke S, Uberschär KH, Valenta H, Schnurrbusch U, Ganter M, Klobasa F, Flachowsky G, 2003, Effects of graded levels of Fusarium toxin contaminated maize in diets for female weaned piglets, Arch Anim Nutr 57, 311-34. 8. Döll S, Dänicke S, Valenta H, Flachowsky G, 2004, In vitro studies on the evaluation of mycotoxin detoxifying agents for their efficacy on deoxynivalenol and Zearalenone, Arch Anim Nutr 58, 311-24. 9. Döll S, Gericke S, Dänicke S, Raila J, Uberschär KH et al, 2005, The efficacy of a modified aluminosilicate as a detoxifying agent in Fusarium toxin contaminated maize containing diets for piglets, J Anim Physiol Anim Nut, 89, 342-58. 10. EFSA, 2004, Opinion on zearelenone, The EFSA Journal, 89, 1-35. 11. Evans T, 2000, Measurment of vulvae index as fusariotoxicoses parameter. Personal communication. College of Vet. Med. Univ. Missouri, Colorado, NO 65211. 12. Gaumy JL, Bailly JD, Benard G, Guerre G, 2001, Zearalenone: origin and effect on farm animals, Rev Med Vet, 152, 123-36. 13. Humphreys J, 1988, Veterinary Toxicology, 3rd ed, Baillere Tindall Comp, London, Great Britain. 14. Jadamus A, Schneider D, 2002, Long-term effect of fusariotoxins on the reproduction performance of sows testing the effectiveness of detoxifying feed additives 700, Feed Magazine 10, 396-405. 15. Kyriakis SC, Papaioannou DS, Alexopoulos C, Polizopoulou Z, Tzika ED et al, 2002, Experimental studies on safety and efficacy of the dietary use of a clinoptilolite-rich tuff in sows: a review of recent research in Greece, Micropor Mesopor Mat, 51, 65-74. 16. Logrieco A, Mule G, Moretti A, Bottalico A, 2002, Toxigenic Fusarium species and mycotoxins associated with maiz ear rot in Europe, Eur J Plant Pathol, 108, 597-609. 17. Mitterbauer R, Weindorfer H, Safaie N, Krska R, Lemmens M, Ruckenbauer KKGAP, 2003, A Sensitive and Inexpensive Yeast Bioassay for the Mycotoxin Zearalenone and Other Compounds with Estrogenic Activity, Appl Environ Microbiol, 69, 2, 805-11. 18. National Toxicology Program, 2002, National Toxicology Program carcinogenesis bioassay of Zearalenone in F344/N rats and F6C3F1 mice, National Toxicology Program Technical Report Series, vol. 235. Department of Health and Human Services, Research Triangle Park, N.C. 19. Scheuer PJ, Chalk BT, 1986, Clinical test: Histopatology, Wolfe medical Publ. Inc, London. 20. Snedecor WG, Cochran GW, 1971, Statistical Methods. The Iowa State Univ Press. 21. Swamy HVLN, Smith TK, MacDonald EJ, Boermans HJ, Squires EJ, 2002, Effects of feeding a blend of grains naturally contaminated with Fusarium mycotoxins on swine performance, brain regional neurochemistry, and serum chemistry and the efficacy of a polymeric glucomannan mycotoxin adsorbent, J Anim Sci, 80, 3257-67. 22. Toma{evi}-^anovi} M, Dakovi} A, Rottinghaus G, Matija{evi} S, \uri~i} M, 2003, Surfactant modified zeolites – new efficient adsorbents for mycotoxins, Micropor Mesopor Mat, 61, 173- 80.


Micotoxicosis prevention
Sign up